The Oldest Nursery Rhymes: What Can Be Dated and Why It Is Hard

The oldest nursery rhymes are older than any book of nursery rhymes. The earliest collection that survives, Tommy Thumb's Pretty Song Book, was printed in London in May 1744. Some rhymes can be traced back a further 150 years or more, through plays, songbooks, dictionaries and books of sayings. How far back, and how sure anyone can be, is what this post is about.

It sets out what can be dated, why dating is harder than a simple list of years suggests, and how the printed collections grew from one small book into the large collections that scholars still use. The table and the counts come from a script that reads our own old nursery rhymes data, not from memory, and every outside fact comes from a source we read, named at the end of the post in our notes.

The short answer

Three different things can be "the oldest", and they have three different answers.

  • The oldest collection. Tommy Thumb's Pretty Song Book, published in London by Mary Cooper in May 1744. Wikipedia calls the two surviving copies the oldest printed collections of English nursery rhymes still in existence. It was the second volume of a pair, and the first volume is lost.
  • The oldest rhyme with a date on our site. Birds of a Feather, at 1545, though what the date marks is a saying, a close relative of the rhyme and not the rhyme in its present form. The first date for a verse that looks like a nursery rhyme is 1580, for Ding Dong Bell, when an organist wrote down an early version with different words.
  • The oldest children's songs of any kind. Lullabies. Wikipedia says they are the oldest children's songs with records, found in every human culture, and that a Roman nurse's lullaby quoted in an ancient commentary on the poet Persius may be the oldest one to survive. It survives because someone copied the words down, which is true of very few lullabies.

So a fair answer to "what is the oldest nursery rhyme?" is that nobody can say for certain, and the rest of this post explains why.

Why dating a nursery rhyme is hard

A date next to a rhyme is almost never the day it was made. It is the earliest day we can prove it existed, and those are very different things. Four problems keep coming up.

First print is not first use. Nursery rhymes were said aloud, to babies and by children to each other, long before anyone thought them worth printing. Wikipedia notes that most were not written down until the 1700s, when children's books started to move from teaching and warning towards entertainment, though there is evidence for many of them earlier. It names "To market, to market" and a rooster rhyme as rhymes that go back to at least the late 1500s. A rhyme that mothers had said for fifty years looks, in the records, exactly like one invented the week it appeared in a book.

The proof is often a trace and not a text. Look at the right-hand column of the table below. A date may point to a play in which a character says one line, a dictionary that quotes the opening words, a tune with different words, or a book of proverbs. All of these are real evidence that a rhyme, or its ancestor, was known. None of them is a printed nursery rhyme as we would recognise one.

The books themselves are rare. The first volume of Tommy Thumb's Song Book has not survived at all. Of the second volume, Tommy Thumb's Pretty Song Book, only two copies are known. Cotsen Children's Library at Princeton University noted in 2016 that there were two copies of that volume, one copy of the 1784 edition of Mother Goose's Melody, and one of Gammer Gurton's Garland. When a whole field rests on a handful of tiny books, one new discovery can move a date. The first edition of Mother Goose's Melody, from about 1780, is known only because a newspaper advertised it, according to the British Library, and the oldest surviving copy dates from 1784.

Reference works disagree. The year given for a rhyme depends on what the writer counts as the first appearance. Our page for Old King Cole says 1708, while other reference works give 1709 and name a differently titled work by the same author. For Rain Rain Go Away, the Wikipedia article on nursery rhymes lists 1687, while the article on the rhyme itself, like our page, gives James Howell's book of proverbs in 1659. These are not scandals. They are what the evidence looks like when it is thin, and a careful writer says "about" and names the source.

The oldest dated rhymes on our site

Our collection stands at 972 rhymes. Of those, 65 have a year we can count: either the "first published" field on the rhyme page begins with an exact year, or the history note on the page names one, which is how the old nursery rhymes page is built. The other 907 pages give no exact year. Some are by named authors, some have no known origin, and 13 give only a decade, such as "the 1700s". Those are left out of every count below.

Here are the 15 oldest of the 65, in date order.

YearRhymeWhat the date points to
1545Birds of a FeatherA 1545 satire has an older form of the saying; the modern wording is in a 1599 dictionary
1580Ding Dong BellAn organist, John Lant, wrote down an early version with different words
1585A Duck and a DrakeAn English book printed in 1585 already used the phrase for stone skimming
1603Hush, Hush, Hush, Hush!Lines taken from a play, The Pleasant Comedy of Patient Grissell
1609Three Blind MiceThe tune, printed in the songbook Deuteromelia; the words were quite different
1639Jack SpratRecorded as a saying in John Clarke's book of proverbs
1659Rain Rain Go AwayA line about sending rain to Spain, in James Howell's book of proverbs
1671A Was an Apple PieThe first lines are quoted in a book by John Eachard
1687A Swarm of Bees in MayQuoted in a French and English dictionary printed in London
1695Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, SailorA similar line is spoken in a play by William Congreve
1698Pat-a-CakeA nurse says a version of it in the comedy The Campaigners
1708Old King ColeOur page says 1708, in a book by William King; other reference works say 1709, so treat it as about 1708 or 1709
1719One Misty Moisty MorningA longer version was printed in a song collection
1728This Little PiggyOnly the first line, in a medley called The Nurses Song; the full rhyme is about 1760
1733Hot Cross BunsA street cry printed in a London almanac for 1733

Read the right-hand column before you quote the left. Some of these have their own history notes, such as Pat-a-Cake, which is first recorded in a play of 1698. Three Blind Mice is dated 1609 because a tune of that name was printed in a songbook that year, but the words in it are not the words children learn now. This Little Piggy is dated 1728 for a single line, and the full rhyme turns up about thirty years later. In each case the year is a clue, not a birth certificate.

One year stands out in the next group. 7 of our rhymes carry the date 1744 or about 1744: Hickory Dickory Dock, Baa Baa Black Sheep, Little Boy Blue, Little Tommy Tucker, London Bridge Is Falling Down, Mary, Mary, Quite Contrary and Sing a Song of Sixpence. Six of the seven are in the contents of Tommy Thumb's Pretty Song Book as Wikipedia lists them. Our page for Little Boy Blue ties it to a Tommy Thumb song book without saying which, and we leave it at that. One small book gave the English-speaking world a large part of its nursery.

How many per century

Counting the 65 rhymes with an exact year by the century of that year gives a picture of when our dated rhymes first reach print.

Century of the dateRhymes on our site
1500s3
1600s8
1700s29
1800s24
1900s1

The jump in the 1700s is real, and it matches what Wikipedia says about the century: printing for children took off, and the collectors followed. Only 15 of the 65 predate the 1744 book. The 1800s are not far behind, and that count includes poems by named authors, such as the 1806 poem by Jane Taylor that became Twinkle Twinkle Little Star. In all, 10 of the 65 dated pages have a named author.

How the collections grew

The history of nursery rhymes in print is, to a large extent, the history of a few small books and the people who copied from them. Here are the main steps, in order.

  1. 1744: Tommy Thumb. Tommy Thumb's Pretty Song Book was printed from copper plates in alternate red and black ink, according to Wikipedia, in a book only about three inches by under two. It holds forty rhymes, many of them still in use. One copy is in the British Library, and a second copy that appeared in 2001 is now at Cotsen Children's Library.
  2. 1780 to 1784: Mother Goose. Thomas Carnan, the stepson of the publisher John Newbery, brought out Mother Goose's Melody, or Sonnets for the Cradle. The British Library, which bought a 1791 copy, says it contains the first recorded appearance in print of many rhymes we still know and that later British and North American collections were built on it. We tell the story of the name in Who Was Mother Goose? Three of our pages, Rock-a-Bye Baby, See Saw Margery Daw and Hey Diddle Diddle, say "about 1765" for it. That is an older dating, and the earliest evidence we found is the advertisement of 1780.
  3. 1784: Gammer Gurton's Garland. Joseph Ritson, an antiquary from Stockton-on-Tees, published 79 rhymes in a twopenny chapbook. According to Wikipedia it was the first printing of rhymes including Bye, Baby Bunting, Goosey Goosey Gander and "I see the moon". Only one copy of that first edition is known, in the British Library. A third edition of 1810 added 55 more rhymes to the original 79.
  4. 1826 to 1849: the collectors. Robert Chambers published Popular Rhymes of Scotland in 1826. In 1842 James Orchard Halliwell, later Halliwell-Phillipps, issued The Nursery Rhymes of England, which Wikipedia calls the first, and possibly the most important, academic collection in the field. He sorted the rhymes into groups such as riddles, alphabet rhymes, game rhymes and lullabies, and followed it with a sequel in 1849. His name is in the history notes of 230 of our rhyme pages, more than any other collector.
  5. 1895 to 1897: the footnotes arrive. Sabine Baring-Gould's A Book of Nursery Songs (1895) and Andrew Lang's The Nursery Rhyme Book (1897) treated the rhymes as a subject for study, with comments and notes on each.
  6. 1951: the Opies. Iona and Peter Opie published The Oxford Dictionary of Nursery Rhymes in 1951, and Wikipedia calls it still the standard work, revised by Iona Opie in 1997. They worked from printed books and, as their research went on, from interviews with thousands of schoolchildren.

Our own pages show the same layers. Of our 972 rhyme pages, 8 name a Tommy Thumb book in their history notes, 11 name Mother Goose's Melody and 16 name Gammer Gurton's Garland. Halliwell's far larger count shows how much of what we know about English rhymes was gathered in the 1840s, not the 1740s.

What dates can and cannot tell you

When you see a year beside a nursery rhyme, in this post or anywhere else, these habits keep you honest.

  • Ask what the year marks. A full printed rhyme, a single line, a tune, a mention in a play and a line in a dictionary are five different kinds of evidence.
  • Say "earliest known". Never "made in" or "written in". For most traditional rhymes nobody knows who made them or when.
  • Treat "about" as honest, not vague. "About 1744" tells you the book had no printed date and scholars worked it out from other clues.
  • Expect the date to move. A long-lost anthology turned up in the autumn of 2015, according to Cotsen Children's Library, and another find can happen again. A rhyme's earliest year can only get earlier.
  • Do not expect a story to come with the date. A year says when a rhyme was recorded. It does not say what the words were about, and we do not guess in this post.

The nursery rhyme as an idea is younger than most of the rhymes, which is covered in What Is a Nursery Rhyme? The phrase itself dates only from about 1800, per Wikipedia, which is why the older records use words like "songs" or "Tommy Thumb's songs".

Where to read the originals

The British Library's short article "Before they were bedtime stories: the first printed nursery rhymes" is the best plain-English account we found of the early collections, written by one of its curators of printed heritage. It shows pages from Mother Goose's Melody and notes that the library also holds one of only two surviving copies of Tommy Thumb's Pretty Song Book. If a rhyme you love is on our old nursery rhymes page, open its own page for the old wording and the book it came from.

Try these

Pick one rhyme from the table and find out what its date points to before you tell a child how old it is. Then say it aloud. Whoever first said it to a baby did exactly the same, with no book to look at, and that was the real beginning of every date on this page.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the oldest nursery rhyme?
Nobody can say for certain. The oldest date on our site is 1545, for a saying that became Birds of a Feather. The first verse with the look of a nursery rhyme is Ding Dong Bell, written down by an organist in about 1580 with different words.
What is the oldest collection of nursery rhymes?
Tommy Thumb's Pretty Song Book, published in London in May 1744. Two copies survive. It was the second volume of a pair, and the first volume has been lost.
Why is it hard to date a nursery rhyme?
Rhymes were said aloud long before they were printed, so the first printing only shows the latest date by which a rhyme existed. Early evidence is often a line in a play, a tune or a proverb, and only a few tiny books from the 1700s survive.
When were nursery rhymes first written down?
Records of short children's rhymes go back to the later Middle Ages and appear in English plays from the mid-1500s, but most were not written down until the 1700s, when books for children began to be printed in numbers.