What Shoe-maker Makes Shoes Without Leather Lyrics

Ages 5-10Mother Goose

Which shoemaker uses no leather, yet puts fire, water, earth and air together and gives every customer two pair? The book that prints it gives the answer: a horse-shoer.

What Shoe-maker Makes Shoes Without Leather

What shoe-maker makes shoes without leather,
With all the four elements put together?
Fire and water, earth and air;
Ev'ry customer has two pair.

Type
Mother Goose
How to say it
Spoken slowly, with a pause before the last line
Best for ages
5 to 10 years

What Does What Shoe-maker Makes Shoes Without Leather Mean?

The answer is a horse-shoer, someone who fits shoes on horses. The riddle plays on the word shoes: these shoes are not made of leather, because a horse's shoes are made of metal. The clue that gives it away is the last line. A horse has four feet, so every customer needs two pair.

The third line names four elements, fire and water, earth and air, as if the shoemaker used everything in the world at once, but the answer does not need them. They are there for the sound and the sense of a grand trade. Leather rhymes with together, and air with pair.

History and Origin

James Orchard Halliwell includes the riddle in The Nursery Rhymes of England, first published in 1842; the printing used here is the 1886 one from Frederick Warne, London. The book prints the answer, a horse-shoer, with the riddle.

Learning Activities

  • Guess first: read the riddle without the last line and let the child guess before reading on.
  • Count the feet: look at a picture of a horse and count its feet, then pair them off.
  • Horseshoe look: look at a picture of a horseshoe and say what it is made of.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a person who makes horseshoes called today?
A farrier.
Why does the riddle say two pair?
A horse has four feet, and shoes are counted in pairs, so each horse needs two pair.