There Was a Man Who Had No Eyes Lyrics

Ages 5-10Mother Goose

A man with no eyes goes out to view the skies, sees a tree with apples on it, takes no apples off and yet leaves no apples on it. The book's answer: the man had one eye, and the tree two apples.

There Was a Man Who Had No Eyes

There was a man who had no eyes,
He went abroad to view the skies;
He saw a tree with apples on it,
He took no apples off, yet left no apples on it.

Type
Mother Goose
How to say it
Spoken slowly, with a pause before the last line
Best for ages
5 to 10 years

Hand Motions and Actions

When you singDo this
He went abroad to view the skies;Cover one eye with a hand and tip your head back to look up.
He saw a tree with apples on it,Reach up as if picking an apple, then show two fingers.

What Does There Was a Man Who Had No Eyes Mean?

The answer in the book is that the man had one eye, and the tree two apples upon it. The words stay true while the picture changes. A man with one eye has no eyes in the sense of having no pair, and the tree with two apples works the same way: he took one apple and left one, so he took no pair off and left no pair on.

That is how the riddle plays on the little word no. It rhymes eyes with skies, and the third and fourth lines carry the trick, with the tongue-tying no apples off and no apples on set side by side.

History and Origin

Halliwell gives this riddle in his Nursery Rhymes of England, with the answer that is used here.

Learning Activities

  • Eye test: cover one eye and look at an object, then switch, and notice what changes.
  • Apple count: draw a tree with two apples, then cross out one and say how many are left.
  • Make a trick: write a new riddle with a plain answer hidden in a small word.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does abroad mean in the second line?
Out of doors. It is an old sense of the word, not a trip to another country.
Which two words rhyme?
Eyes and skies.