Lives in Winter, Dies in Summer (Riddle) Lyrics

Ages 4-9Mother Goose

It lives in the cold, disappears in the warm, and grows from the top down. A three-line riddle about something you can see on a frosty morning.

Lives in Winter, Dies in Summer (Riddle)

Lives in winter,
Dies in summer,
And grows with its roots upward!

Type
Mother Goose
Tune
Spoken riddle
Best for ages
4 to 9 years

What Does Lives in Winter, Dies in Summer (Riddle) Mean?

Each of the three clues sounds like a plant, and that is the trick. It lives in winter and dies in summer, and it grows with its roots upward. Every plant you know does the opposite: it grows in summer, rests in winter, and has its roots in the ground. The answer is an icicle. It forms from dripping water when the weather is freezing, melts when the weather warms, and hangs from a roof or branch so the thick end is at the top, like roots above and tip below.

This is a good riddle for a cold morning. Go outside, look for icicles, and ask the child to check the clues. The "roots upward" line is the one that makes children laugh when they realize it. You can also use it to start a conversation about how ice is made, why it hangs down and how fast it grows on a sunny day. For a harder challenge, give the clues one at a time and see how many it takes. Most people need all three before the answer arrives.

History and Origin

Halliwell included this riddle in the "Riddles" chapter of The Nursery Rhymes of England (first published 1842) with its answer in brackets: "An Icicle". The Real Mother Goose (1916) prints it too, giving the answer as the title. Both versions have the same three lines, so the wording barely changed between the 1840s and 1916.

Neither book names an author or a place where it was told, and no earlier printing is known. Riddles about natural things like ice, snow, dew and eggs were a favorite kind in English collections, and Halliwell grouped many of them together, which suggests they were told aloud in households for a long time before being collected. Beyond that, the riddle's age is unknown. It is a good example of a riddle that works because the clues are true, not because they are clever wordplay.

Learning Activities

  • Guess first: give the clues one at a time and let your child guess.
  • Freeze test: freeze water in a cup and watch it melt again.
  • Icicle hunt: look for icicles on a cold day, from a safe distance.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the answer?
An icicle.
Why does it grow with its roots upward?
Icicles hang from the top and grow downward, with the thick end at the top.
What is the answer to the riddle?
An icicle. It lives in winter, melts in summer, and hangs with its thick end at the top.