A Puppy's Problem Lyrics

Ages 3-7Poems for Children

Midget the puppy is taught to bite, then told off for it, taught to bark, then hushed, and the poem ends with her learning when each one is allowed.

A Puppy's Problem

When Midget was a puppy,
And to the farm was brought,
She found that there were many things
A puppy must be taught.

Her mother oft had told her
The first thing to be known
Was how to gnaw and bite, and thus
Enjoy a toothsome bone.

So Midget practiced biting
On everything around,
But that was not approved at all,
To her surprise, she found.

The farmer spoke severely,
Till Midget shook with fright;
The children shouted "No, no, no!
Bad Midget! Mustn't bite!"

'Twas just the same with barking;
At first they all said "Hark!"
Whenever Midget tried her voice;
"Good puppy! that's it! Bark!"

But then, as soon as Midget
Could sound a sharp "Bow-wow!"
Alas! the talk was changed to "Hush!
Such noise we can't allow."

Now wasn't that a puzzle?
It seemed a problem dark,
That it was right and wrong to bite
And right and wrong to bark.

A puppy's hardest lesson
Is when to bark and bite;
But Midget learned it, and became
A comfort and delight.

Type
Poems for Children, Animal Rhymes
Written by
Emilie Poulsson
How to say it
Say it with a puzzled voice for the muddled rules, then switch to a pleased voice for the last four lines.
Best for ages
3 to 7 years

Hand Motions and Actions

When you singDo this
Bad Midget! Mustn't bite!Wag a finger gently, then clasp your hands behind your back.
Bow-wow!Cup your hands around your mouth and give one small bark.

What Does A Puppy's Problem Mean?

A puppy cannot tell the difference between what is welcomed and what is not, and Midget's problem is exactly that: the same noise gets praise one minute and a scolding the next. Her mother told her to practise gnawing and biting on a bone, but she practised on everything, and the farmer and the children said no. Then Hark! brought a cheer for a first bark, and a sharp Bow-wow! brought Hush!.

The poem calls this a puzzle, a problem dark, which here means hard to work out. Midget does not solve it with words. She learns when to bark and when to bite, and becomes a comfort and delight.

History and Origin

Emilie Poulsson (1853-1939) was an American children's author who also campaigned for early childhood education and the kindergarten movement. Pinafore Palace (1907) lists this poem as printed with permission from her book Through the Farmyard Gate.

Learning Activities

  • When to bark: list together some times a dog should bark and some times it should be quiet, and act out one of each.
  • Teach the puppy: one child plays Midget, another gives a calm word for each rule in the poem.

Frequently Asked Questions

What does the poem mean by a problem dark?
A problem that is hard to see through. Midget cannot understand why barking is sometimes right and sometimes wrong.